Can You Mix Different Types of Engine Oil? What Experts Say

Engine oil is a vital component in keeping your vehicle running smoothly. It lubricates the engine’s moving parts, reduces friction, prevents overheating, and helps maintain overall performance. But what happens when you find yourself needing to top up your oil and don’t have the exact same brand or type you last used? This leads to a common question among vehicle owners: Can you mix different types of engine oil?

Auto Inc Tanzania is your trusted destination for all car needs. We offer expert car services, premium accessories, and high-quality automotive products. From maintenance to upgrades, our solutions are tailored for every vehicle model, ensuring reliability, style, and affordability. Drive confidently with Auto Inc Tanzania’s exceptional care and customer satisfaction. 

In this article, we explore what experts say about mixing engine oils, the science behind it, and whether it's safe or potentially damaging to your car engine.

Understanding Engine Oil Basics

Before diving into whether mixing is safe, it’s important to understand the types of engine oils available. Broadly, there are three categories:

1. Conventional (Mineral) Oil – Made from refined crude oil, it’s the most basic type and is generally cheaper.
   
   

2. Synthetic Oil – Man-made with high-performance chemical compounds, synthetic oil offers better lubrication, cleaner operation, and longer life.
   
   

3. Semi-Synthetic Oil – A blend of synthetic and mineral oils, this type offers moderate performance and affordability.
   

Each type comes in different viscosity grades (e.g., 5W-30, 10W-40), which indicates how the oil behaves at different temperatures. Mixing different types or viscosities is where things get complicated.

Can You Mix Different Brands of the Same Type?

If you're using two brands of the same type of oil—for instance, two synthetic 5W-30 oils—the general consensus is that it's usually safe. Most engine oils on the market today are manufactured to meet industry standards set by organizations like the API (American Petroleum Institute) and ACEA (European Automobile Manufacturers’ Association). This means they are designed to be broadly compatible.

However, oil formulations can vary in additives, detergents, and performance enhancers. While mixing different brands is not recommended as a long-term solution, it’s unlikely to cause immediate harm if done occasionally.

What About Mixing Synthetic and Conventional Oil?

Here’s where it gets more interesting. Can you mix synthetic oil with conventional oil? The answer is yes, but with caveats.

✔️ What Happens When You Mix Synthetic with Conventional Oil?

• The blend will still offer lubrication and protection to your engine.
  
  

• The performance level will generally be lowered to the lesser quality oil (usually conventional).
  
  

• Additive compatibility can be an issue, leading to reduced effectiveness.
  

What Experts Say:

Most auto manufacturers and oil brands suggest that mixing synthetic and conventional oil should only be a temporary solution, such as when you’re in an emergency and the right oil isn’t available. You should get a proper oil change soon after to restore optimal engine performance.

Is It Safe to Mix Different Viscosity Grades?

Mixing oils of different viscosity grades (e.g., 10W-30 and 5W-30) can create an intermediate grade that isn’t precisely defined. While modern engines are built to handle some variation, too much deviation can affect engine performance, especially in extreme temperatures.

For example, mixing 5W-30 (better for cold starts) with 10W-40 (thicker at high temps) may alter how the oil flows at both low and high temperatures. It might not lubricate as effectively as a single, correct-grade oil.

Expert Insight:

According to most mechanics and oil engineers, mixing viscosities in an emergency situation is acceptable as long as both oils meet the engine’s minimum requirements and are API-approved. But it's not advisable as a regular practice.

Keep your engine running smoothly with Auto Inc’s professional Tyre Service. We use high-quality oils to ensure optimal performance and longevity for your vehicle. Combine this with our wide range of car services, accessories, and products for a complete car care experience. Trust Auto Inc for excellence and reliability.

What Are the Risks of Mixing Incompatible Oils?

Here are potential issues when mixing incompatible oils:

• Foaming and Separation – Additives might not mix well, causing foam or oil separation.
  
  

• Reduced Lubrication – If viscosity becomes too thin or too thick, parts may not be lubricated properly.
  
  

• Sludge Formation – Incompatible detergents may lead to sludge or deposits in the engine.
  
  

• Voiding Warranty – Some car manufacturers specify certain oils, and using a mixed or incorrect one could void warranties.
  

Situations Where Mixing Is Acceptable

There are a few scenarios where mixing engine oils is considered acceptable:

1. Emergency Top-Ups: If your engine is low on oil and you're far from an oil shop or service station, it's better to mix oils than run with insufficient oil.
   
   

2. Short-Term Use: If you mix oils, plan to schedule a full oil change soon.
   
   

3. Blending with Semi-Synthetics: Since semi-synthetic oils are already a mix, adding either synthetic or conventional oil typically won’t harm the engine temporarily.
   

How to Safely Mix Engine Oils (If You Must)

If you absolutely have to mix different oils, here are some tips to reduce risk:

• Stick to the same brand if possible.
  
  

• Choose oils that have similar viscosity grades (e.g., 5W-30 and 10W-30).
  
  

• Ensure both oils meet manufacturer specifications and API standards.
  
  

• Avoid mixing in high-performance or turbocharged engines, which are more sensitive to oil quality.
  
  

• Schedule a complete oil change soon afterward.
  

What Do Oil Manufacturers Say?

Most leading oil manufacturers like Mobil 1, Castrol, and Shell agree: mixing oils is not ideal, but it won’t immediately damage your engine if done rarely or in emergencies.

Mobil 1, for instance, states on its website that mixing synthetic and conventional oils is safe temporarily but should not be standard practice. Castrol also warns against combining oils with vastly different properties or specifications.

Regular oil maintenance is one of the easiest and most effective ways to prolong your vehicle's engine and avoid costly repairs. Mixing oil types may get you by in a pinch, but it’s always better to maintain consistency with oil changes and use high-quality oil that meets your car’s needs.

Conclusion

Understanding engine oil is essential for any car owner, and while mixing different types might seem harmless, the risks—especially long term—can outweigh the convenience. The best practice is always to use the recommended oil type, grade, and brand, and avoid mixing unless it’s absolutely necessary.

If you ever find yourself unsure about which oil to use or whether you’ve mixed oils that are compatible, it’s a good idea to consult your mechanic or refer to your vehicle owner’s manual.